Top Tips for Oysters at Home

Oysters 101

Shucking oysters & busting myths

Diving deep (for oysters) to get you everything you need to know about, well, oysters. Technically, that’s a euphemism—oysters thrive in shallow, briny waters where saltwater and freshwater meet: estuaries, bays, and coastal inlets.

Now, our top tips for how to prepare oysters, what to eat with them, and all the basics of looking like you know exactly what you’re doing when it comes to the world of oysters.

Members: Ready to host like a pro? Your exclusive Partytrick perks are waiting.

1. Meet the Oysters

Not all oysters taste the same. Their flavor is shaped by where they’re grown (hello, merroir), water temperature, and salinity.

Atlantic oysters
Bright, briny, and clean with a crisp finish. A raw bar classic.

Pacific oysters
Creamier and slightly sweet, often with subtle melon or cucumber notes.

Kumamoto oysters
Petite, deeply cupped, and delicately sweet with a buttery texture. A favorite for refined entertaining.

2. How do you shuck an oyster?

Shucking is the art of opening the shell while preserving the oyster (and your fingers). It’s less about force and more about finesse.

What you'll need:

Fresh oysters
Oyster knife (short, sturdy, blunt-tipped)
Thick towel or cut-resistant glove
A plate of crushed ice or rock salt

Steps to shuck oysters

1. Check the oysters: Live oysters should be tightly closed or close when tapped. If one stays open, discard it.

2. Clean the oysters: Rinse under cold running water and scrub off any debris.

3. Secure the oyster: Hold it flat-side up with the hinge facing you. Protect your hand with a towel or glove.

4. Find the hinge: The hinge is where the two shell halves meet—the toughest part of the shell.

5. Insert the oyster knife: Gently wiggle the tip into the hinge. Patience is key.

6. Twist the knife: Once inserted, twist gently to pop the shell open.

7. Cut the muscle: Slide the knife along the inside of the top shell to release the muscle.

8. Remove the top shell: Lift it off completely.

9. Check for fragments: Inspect for shell pieces and remove if needed.

10. Serve and enjoy: Nestle the oyster into crushed ice, level the shell, and carry on with the rest of our tips below.

3. What are the best oyster accouterments?

Don’t overload your oyster. A light touch lets the natural brine shine.

Our favorites:

A squeeze of lemon
Red wine vinegar & shallot mignonette
Freshly grated horseradish
Classic cocktail sauce

4. Oyster pairing: What’s best to drink?

Staying hydrated is key—as always.

Champagne and other dry sparkling wines
Crisp Muscadet or Chablis
A classic dry martini
Guinness (and other stouts) for a bold, iconic pairing

Keep bottles well chilled and pours light. Oysters are about flow, not heaviness.

For your best Champagne experience… consider how stemware affects aroma and effervescence. The details matter.

5. Other ways to eat oysters

Variety keeps your oyster prep interesting—if you weren’t already spicing things up by venturing into oysters.

Grill them
One of our favorite methods. They naturally open when heated, no pre-shucking required. Finish with garlic-herb butter or green chile butter. Check out some of our favorite grilled oyster recipes:

Fried oysters
Crisp exterior, tender center. Ideal for sliders or atop a chic salad. Check out this recipe.

Oysters Rockefeller
Buttery, herbaceous, baked to golden perfection.

Oyster chowder or oyster dip
Comforting, crowd-friendly, and ideal for larger gatherings.

Myth Busters

Since oysters come from a far-off land often associated with mermaids and pirates, here’s our attempt to bust open the myths—and maybe find a hidden pearl.

Oysters are aphrodisiacs… or are they?

They’re high in zinc, which plays a role in hormone production. Science aside, we’ll let you make the final call. Ambiance tends to do most of the heavy lifting.

Our team of Partytrickers did a bit of sleuthing here, we’ll let you make the final call here.

Can you find pearls in the oysters you eat?

Yes—but it’s rare.

Pearls form when an irritant gets trapped inside the oyster’s soft body. The oyster coats it with layers of nacre over time, eventually forming a pearl.

That said, oysters harvested for eating rarely contain pearls. Still, it’s a fun fact to drop at your next dinner party.

Only eat oysters in months with the letter “R”?

This tradition dates back to pre-refrigeration days, when warmer months increased the risk of spoilage. Today, with modern harvesting standards and proper sourcing, oysters can be safely enjoyed year-round. The key is working with reputable suppliers and proper storage.

Are bigger oysters better?

Not necessarily—it depends on your preference and preparation.

‍Taste and texture:
Smaller oysters are often sweeter and more delicate. Larger oysters can be meatier and more robust.
Consistency and presentation:
Uniform sizing elevates a raw bar aesthetically.‍
Preparation:
Larger oysters hold up beautifully to grilling and baking. Smaller oysters shine on the half shell.

Now, it’s time to get out there and make use of all the oyster knowledge you now have. Why not keep the night entertaining and impress your guests with the fun facts you’ve picked up? Go-to oyster game: Busting myths & shucking oysters.